How to Audit an Etsy Shop: Yours First, Then a Competitor’s

Updated by

An Etsy shop audit is a count of what is missing across your listings: empty tag slots, thin titles, too few photos, no video, short descriptions, no materials, listings outside a section and an empty shop announcement. Audit your own shop first, starting with the two reports Etsy already gives you. Then run the same checks on one competitor, and treat only the gaps between the two shops as your to-do list.

Start with the two reports Etsy already gives you

For your own shop, Etsy has done part of the audit. Shop Manager has a page called Etsy search visibility, split into three areas: your listings, your shop and your customer service. Etsy says a listing that falls short there may be shown less in search. Its checks are basic, and worth clearing first:

  • a primary photo that is one clear, well-lit image of the finished item, not a collage, ideally 2000 pixels or more on each side (Etsy image sizes has the rest)
  • the most specific category that fits
  • a return policy on every listing, even if it says “No returns”
  • a shop logo, which Etsy lists as part of a complete shop

The customer service area covers replying to messages in time, shipping on time with tracking, keeping a positive review score and avoiding a high number of cases. Messages, shipping and reviews also decide the Star Seller badge.

The second report is Shop Manager › Stats. Before you change a single listing, work out which problem you have. Few visits means shoppers are not finding the listings, and the fix is in titles, tags and attributes. Healthy visits with few orders means they arrive and leave, and the fix is in photos, price, description and shipping. Views versus visits explains how to read the two. When sales drop, Etsy’s own advice is to compare longer periods, such as year over year, rather than a single month, and to replace search terms that bring no traffic.

The listing checklist

Etsy’s report does not look at tags, titles, descriptions or video. The checks below do, and each one works the same way on any shop, yours or someone else’s, because every field is visible on the listing page. The limits are Etsy’s. The “flag it when” column is the line our free analyzer uses: a judgement, not an Etsy rule.

CheckEtsy’s limitFlag it when
Tags13 per listing, 20 characters eachFewer than 13, or the same tag twice
Title length140 characters60 characters or fewer, or 135 or more
Repeated title wordsEtsy advises against repeating wordsOne word 3 or more times in a title
PhotosUp to 20Fewer than 5
VideoUp to 2, each 5 to 15 secondsNone
DescriptionFree textUnder 300 characters, about 50 words
MaterialsOptional fieldNone listed on a physical item
Shop sectionOptionalListing is in no section
Shop announcementOptionalEmpty

A title near 140 characters is not wrong in itself, but Etsy Help notes that search engines show only the first 50 to 60 characters of a page title, so check that the words naming the item come first. A video helps the shopper who already found the listing; it does little to help them find it.

Etsy’s list of the search factors sellers control starts with tag and title relevance and item attribute relevance, then listing quality and customer and market experience. That is a sensible order for fixes too: empty tag slots and thin titles come before video, and a better description will not rescue a listing nobody finds.

Doing this by hand means opening every listing page. The free Etsy shop analyzer runs these checks on the newest 100 active listings of any shop and shows how many fail each one, with three example listings per issue. It needs no account and changes nothing on Etsy.

A competitor’s shop: what you can and cannot see

The same checklist works on a competitor, and that is the part most competitor research skips: it compares their numbers, not their listings. Pick a shop that sells the same kind of product at a similar price and opened around the same time. The biggest shop in your category has years of reviews you cannot match this month, so its numbers say little about what you should fix.

What Etsy publishes for any shop: total sales since it opened (a count, not money), reviews and average rating, the month it opened, active listings, shop favorites and location, and on each listing its price, photos, video and tags. The free Etsy shop stats lookup reads those for any shop and adds the median price, the share of listings with a video and the 15 tags it uses most.

What Etsy keeps private: revenue, visits, views, conversion rate, sales in a given month and what the shop spends on Etsy Ads. A tool that shows those for someone else’s shop is estimating. Total sales times an average price is not revenue either: the count covers every sale since the shop opened, at whatever the prices were then.

Read the gap, not the scorecard

Run the analyzer on your shop and on theirs, and put the counts side by side. An example with sample numbers, not a real shop:

  • Fewer than 13 tags: yours 38 of 100 listings, theirs 4. A real gap, and your first batch.
  • No video: yours 90, theirs 85. Both fail, so it is not what separates you.
  • Short description: yours 6, theirs 41. Not your problem. Do not pad yours to match.

Three rules come out of that. A check where they are clean and you are not is a to-do item. A check where both shops fail is not their advantage. A check where you are clean and they are not tells you nothing about what to change.

Their tags deserve one more look. The tags a shop repeats across many listings are the phrases it is betting on. Where one honestly describes your product, test it in a listing. Never copy shop or brand names, phrases that do not fit what you sell, or their titles, descriptions and photos. Etsy keyword research covers how to judge a phrase before you use it.

Fix one batch, date it, then audit again

Pick one check, fix it across the listings it flagged, and write down the date. Etsy says changes can take up to a day to show in search; sales take longer to move, so give a batch a few weeks in Stats before you judge it. Changing every field on every listing at once leaves you no way to tell what worked.

Then run the audit again. The count for the check you fixed should fall to zero or close to it, and the next check becomes the next batch. An audit counts gaps you can fix. It is not a prediction of sales, and no checklist rescues a product, price or photo that buyers do not want.

Checked on 17 November 2026 against Etsy Help: How to Use the Etsy Search Visibility Page, How to Use Etsy Stats for Your Shop, What to Do If You Notice a Drop in Sales, How to Create a Listing, How to Use Tags to Get Found in Search, Search Engine Optimization (SEO) for Shop and Listing Pages and How to Open an Etsy Shop. Etsy changes these pages without notice, so check them before you build a routine around any one rule.

Frequently asked questions

How often should I audit my Etsy shop?

After each batch of fixes has had a few weeks to show in Stats, and whenever Stats shows a drop that the season does not explain. Auditing every week mostly measures changes that have not had time to work.

Can I see how much money another Etsy shop makes?

No. Etsy publishes a shop's total sales count, reviews, rating, age, active listings and favorites, but not its revenue, visits, conversion rate or monthly sales. Any revenue figure for someone else's shop is an estimate, and total sales times an average price is not revenue.

Is it OK to use a competitor's Etsy tags?

Only the phrases that truly describe your own product. Tags are visible on every listing, and the ones a shop repeats show what it is betting on. Test a phrase that fits your item in one listing; never copy shop or brand names, and never copy titles, descriptions or photos.

Will fixing what the audit finds raise my Etsy ranking?

Not guaranteed. Filling empty tags and writing titles that name the item give Etsy search more to match, and Etsy lists tag, title and attribute relevance among the factors sellers control. But ranking also depends on how shoppers respond, so judge each batch in Stats rather than expecting a result.

Do I need to connect my Etsy shop to audit it?

Not for the free shop analyzer, which reads any shop's newest 100 active listings with no account: one new shop a day, and a shop anyone audited in the last 24 hours opens again at no cost. Connecting adds Shop Audit for your own listings, where the Free plan shows every count and three listings per issue, and Competitor Check: one a month on Free, five on Starter and twenty on Growth.

Run the checklist on a real shop

The free shop analyzer counts every check above across any shop’s newest 100 active listings, and the shop stats lookup shows the numbers Etsy publishes for it. Neither needs an account, and neither changes anything on Etsy.

Try the free tools

No credit card required.